https://jetbis.al-makkipublisher.com/index.php/al/index
571
Journal Of Economics, Technology And Business (JETBIS)
Volume 2, Number 8 August 2023
p-ISSN 2964-903X; e-ISSN 2962-9330
ANALYSIS OF THE NEEDS OF TYPE A TERMINAL INFRASTRUCTURE
FACILITIES IN ARJOSARI, MALANG BASED ON DISASTER MITIGATION
Tri Wahyusetianingsih
1
, Harris Muhammadun
2
, Wateno Oetomo
3
Magister Teknik Sipil, FT Untag Surabaya, Indonesia
Email: ft@untag-sby.ac.id
KEYWORDS:
Infrastructure, Disaster
Mitigation, Arjosari Type A
Terminal
ABSTRACT
A disaster is an event that can be predicted but cannot be known with
certainty when it occurs. Recently, the intensity of natural disasters has
increased, in the form of landslides, floods, earthquakes, tidal waves,
typhoons, and volcanic eruptions. This needs to be watched out for
everyone, including users of public facilities. Currently, there are not
many public facilities that are friendly to disasters, one of which is the
passenger terminal. This study aims to determine the potential
vulnerability of terminal buildings and analyze the availability of
terminal infrastructure facilities and the need for terminal infrastructure
facilities based on disaster mitigation. The method used in the analysis
of the needs of terminal infrastructure facilities is observation,
interviews, and questionnaires, while to determine the potential
vulnerability of terminal buildings using the Rapid Visual Screening
(RVS) worksheet issued by FEMA 154-2015. Efforts made in mitigating
disasters in terminal buildings are through structural mitigation by
carrying out maintenance/rehabilitation of terminal buildings which
include roof repairs, terminal runway repairs and repairs as well as the
addition of evacuation signs.
INTRODUCTION
Based on Malang City Regional Regulation Number 1 of 2017 concerning the Implementation
of Disaster Insurance, it is stated: "the Malang City area has geographical, geological and
demographic conditions that are prone to disasters, both caused by natural factors, non-natural
factors and by human actions that cause environmental damage, property losses, psychological
impacts and casualties which under certain circumstances can hinder national development.”
A disaster is an event that can be predicted but cannot be known with certainty when it occurs
(Putra &; Ismail, 2022). Recently, the intensity of natural disasters has increased, both in the form
of landslides, floods, earthquakes, tidal waves, typhoons, and volcanic eruptions. This needs to be
watched out for everyone (Agustin et al., 2020).
Natural disasters can have a negative impact on people's lives, due to damage to public
facilities, educational facilities, houses of worship, settlements, access roads covered with materials,
split and damaged roads, and so on. In addition, there were quite a lot of casualties, including disaster
victims who had to evacuate and live temporarily in barracks or tents with limited facilities and food
needs (Agustin et al., 2019).
Vol 2, No 8 August 2023
Analysis Of The Needs Of Type A Terminal Infrastructure
Facilities In Arjosari, Malang Based On Disaster Mitigation
https://jetbis.al-makkipublisher.com/index.php/al/index
In 2019, due to the disaster that struck in Malang City, the Regional Disaster Management
Agency (BPBD) of Malang City has recorded that as many as 119 buildings suffered damage with
the following details: 107 units of damaged houses and 7 units of public prasrana buildings, 5 office
units and bridges damaged (Amir, 2012). Damage to infrastructure due to disasters can disrupt
community activities, cause casualties, loss of shelter and damage to ecosystems. In addition, for
infrastructure built by the central and regional governments if they are vulnerable to damage during
a disaster, it can be dangerous for the users of the building, reduced state assets, also to rebuild will
require very large costs (Disaster, 2020). This can burden the State Budget (APBN) and Regional
Budget (APBD). So that early anticipation is needed by all elements of society, this aims to minimize
losses, one of which is when erecting buildings both for settlements and offices must meet standards,
because building construction that does not meet the standards is prone to damage and collapse
during disasters (Birawaputra &; Tethool, 2019).
Public facilities, especially bus terminals, still do not have technical instructions that
specifically regulate how a terminal is prepared to be safe from disasters. Because the terminal is a
gathering place for the community either only as a stopover or a place to carry out economic
activities such as selling at kiosks, selling tickets, as a bus driver and crew, and so on (Edison et al.,
2022). One of the major bus terminals in Malang City, namely Arjosari Terminal located in Blimbing
District. Arjosari Terminal connects districts / cities in East Java Province using AKDP (Intercity
Within Province) buses. In addition, intercity and interprovincial (AKAP) buses are also available
to cross Sumatra, Banten, Jakarta, West Java, Yogyakarta, Central Java, Bali, NTB and NTT. The
number of terminal users coming from the arrival and departure of intercity and interprovincial
(AKAP) and AKDP buses in one day in January 2023 is 5,365 passengers (Suharwoto et al., 2015)
At this time, Arjosari Terminal also still does not support disaster mitigation. In article 21 of
the Regulation of the Minister of Transportation Number PM 24 of 2021, it is stated that the
construction of passenger terminals must provide terminal facilities that meet safety and security
requirements (Bakornas, 2007). This is in line with Law Number 24 of 2007 concerning Disaster
Management in article 47, that disaster mitigation is one of the efforts to reduce disaster risk for
people in disaster-prone locations through the implementation of spatial planning, infrastructure
development, building planning and the implementation of education, counseling, and training both
conventional and modern. In addition, one of the implementation of disaster management during
emergencies is the rescue and evacuation of people affected by disasters and immediate recovery of
vital infrastructure and facilities (State, 2007).
Because the mandate of the regulation has not been realized, with this study, researchers tried
to analyze the availability of Type A Terminal infrastructure as an effort to mitigate disasters (Hakim
&; Sulistijo, 2013). It aims to improve the function of the terminal in addition to serving public
motor vehicles for cross-border transportation or intercity interprovincial transportation also to assist
in reducing the risk and impact of disasters (Bakornas, 2007).
RESEARCH METHODS
Research Location
The location of this research is Arjosari Type A Terminal, Malang, with existing conditions,
as follows:
- Address : Jl. Raden Intan No. 1, Kota Malang
Analysis Of The Needs Of Type A Terminal Infrastructure
Facilities In Arjosari, Malang Based On Disaster Mitigation
Vol 2, No 8 August 2023
https://jetbis.al-makkipublisher.com/index.php/al/index
573
- Coordinate Point : 755'59.6"S 11239‘29.0"E/ -7.933225, 112.658066
Figure 5
Arjosari Type A Terminal Location
Source : https://id.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terminal_Arjosari
Site boundaries: Behind the terminal there is a type C terminal (transportation terminal owned
by the Malang City Government), the right and left are mixed activities between housing, trade,
offices, while at the front is Jl. Raden Intan and settlements.
Figure 6
Arjosari Type A Terminal Land Boundary.
Land : 28.150 m
2
Building Area : 7.343,81 m
2
Terminal Class : II
Year of Development: 1988
Years of Operation : 13 Nopember 1989
Terminal Manager : Ministry of Transportation Directorate General of Land
Transportation Land Transportation Management Center Region XI East Java Province
Stages of Research
The stages carried out in this study include:
a. Formulate research problems and objectives
b. Literature review is the study of theories related to the title. In addition, literature studies are
also
used to collect secondary data related to research, namely data on the number of terminal
users, data on the physical condition of the terminal, data on terminal design plans and what
efforts have been made in dealing with disasters (Utami, 2022).
c. Compiling research variables.
Terminal Tipe
C Kota Malang
Vol 2, No 8 August 2023
Analysis Of The Needs Of Type A Terminal Infrastructure
Facilities In Arjosari, Malang Based On Disaster Mitigation
https://jetbis.al-makkipublisher.com/index.php/al/index
d. Conducting field observations, consisting of questionnaires, interviews and surveys of the
existing condition of terminal infrastructure facilities (Wahyuni, 2018).
e. Collect primary data and secondary data
f. Perform data analysis, with the following stages:
1. Conduct questionnaire data quality tests, namely validity tests and reliability tests.
2. Analyze the characteristics of questionnaire respondents.
3. Analyze interview data.
4. Analyze building vulnerabilities with the Rapid Visual Screening (RVS) worksheet.
5. Analyze the existing condition of terminal infrastructure.
6. Analyze the needs of disaster mitigation-based infrastructure.
7. Prepare a Cost Budget Plan (RAB)
8. Drawing up conclusions and suggestions.
Figure 7
Research Flow Chart
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Questionnaire Analysis Results
a. Respond
Respondents for the distribution of questionnaires in this study consisted of 100 respondents,
namely 17 respondents from Arjosari Terminal officers, 33 respondents from the BPTD Office
Region XI East Java Province as the person in charge of Arjosari Terminal, and 50 respondents
from Arjosari Terminal users (hawkers, stall owners and guards, counter officers, and bus
passengers).
From several characteristics of respondents, namely gender, age, education, and occupation,
it can be seen that terminal users are more likely to be mostly men with an age range of 20-30
Analysis Of The Needs Of Type A Terminal Infrastructure
Facilities In Arjosari, Malang Based On Disaster Mitigation
Vol 2, No 8 August 2023
https://jetbis.al-makkipublisher.com/index.php/al/index
575
years and high school education, so that if a disaster occurs it can move quickly and help other
users. In addition, when disaster response socialization is carried out, it can be easy to understand
and practice what is taught in the socialization.
b. Variable Description Analysis
In this study there are 3 variables, namely hazard variables, vulnerability variables and
capacity variables. For more details can be seen in the following explanation:
Description of Hazard Variables
To find out how much this danger variability affects the respondents can be seen from the
frequency of respondents' responses, as the following table:
Table 1
Recapitulation of respondents' responses to hazard variables (X1)
No
Question
Frekuensi
Jumlah
STS
TS
R
S
SS
1
Potential hazards / disasters that
may occur at Arjosari Terminal
need to be posted on the
information board
2
4
2
41
51
100
2
The distance between Arjosari
Terminal and the disaster
location needs to be conveyed
to Terminal users
1
2
2
48
47
100
Sum
3
6
4
89
98
200
Percentage (%)
1,50%
3,00%
2,00%
44,50%
49,00%
100,00%
Source: Researcher's processed data, 2023
Based on table 1 above, it can be seen that respondents' answers to questions on hazard
variables as much as 49% of respondents' answers were strongly agree, 44.50% agree, 2%
undecided, 3% disagree and 1.5% strongly disagree. This indicates that potential hazards should be
conveyed to the terminal user.
Deskripsi Variabel Kerentanan
To find out how much this vulnerability variable affects respondents, it can be seen from the
frequency of respondent response results, as the following table:
Table 2
Recapitulation of respondents' responses to vulnerability variables (X2)
No
Question
Frequency
Sum
STS
TS
R
S
SS
1
The sturdy Arjosari Terminal
building certainly makes you feel
comfortable
2
6
15
41
36
100
2
The Arjosari Terminal building
has been built in accordance with
decent terminal standards
4
4
40
36
16
100
3
The Arjosari Terminal building
needs to be repaired to be safe
-
2
4
33
61
100
Vol 2, No 8 August 2023
Analysis Of The Needs Of Type A Terminal Infrastructure
Facilities In Arjosari, Malang Based On Disaster Mitigation
https://jetbis.al-makkipublisher.com/index.php/al/index
No
Question
Frequency
Sum
STS
TS
R
S
SS
during a disaster.
4
Arjosari Terminal is equipped
with facilities for the elderly and
disabled (with special needs)
2
4
12
40
42
100
5
Arjosari Terminal waiting room
seats have been arranged to
facilitate evacuation during a
disaster
1
9
12
48
3
73
6
The layout of rooms and kiosks at
Arjosari Terminal makes it easier
during disaster evacuation
-
6
13
52
29
100
7
The existing evacuation routes
are easy to pass and safe.
1
6
14
49
30
100
8
The evacuation route at Arjosari
Terminal is equipped with
evacuation route signs
6
17
19
39
19
100
9
Do you agree if the doors and
windows of Arjosari Terminal
need to be repaired so as to
facilitate the evacuation process
during a disaster
1
4
1
46
48
100
10
Arjosari Terminal Building
already has good natural and
artificial lighting
2
4
17
50
27
100
Sum
19
62
147
434
311
973
Percentage (%)
1,9
5%
6,3
7%
15,1
1%
44,6
0%
31,9
6%
100,0
%
Source: Researcher's processed data, 2023
Based on table 2 above, it can be seen that respondents' answers to questions on vulnerability
variables were 44.60% of respondents' answers, namely agree, 31.96% strongly agree, 15.11%
undecided, 6.37% disagree and 1.95% strongly disagree. From each question it can be concluded
that a sturdy terminal building can make people comfortable, but because of the construction period
of Arjosari Terminal in 1988, it is not known whether it has been built according to standards or not.
The respondents agreed, if repairs were made to the Arjosari Terminal building. According to
respondents, Arjosari Terminal already has a safe evacuation route, easy to pass and has been
equipped with signs.
Capacity Variable Description
To find out how much this capacity variable affects respondents, it can be seen from the
frequency of respondent responses, as the following table:
Analysis Of The Needs Of Type A Terminal Infrastructure
Facilities In Arjosari, Malang Based On Disaster Mitigation
Vol 2, No 8 August 2023
https://jetbis.al-makkipublisher.com/index.php/al/index
577
Table 3
Recapitulation of respondents' responses to the capacity variable (X3)
No
Question
Frekuensi
Sum
STS
TS
R
S
SS
1
Disaster emergency response
information has been
conveyed to terminal users
16
16
14
42
12
100
2
Inside Arjosari Terminal,
disaster emergency response
posters have been installed
19
14
16
38
13
100
3
Socialization and simulation
related to disasters have been
carried out with terminal users
20
14
18
36
12
100
4
Simulations of disaster
occurrence have been carried
out periodically in the Arjosari
Terminal environment
19
13
21
31
16
100
5
Do you agree if regulations are
made about disaster-safe
terminals?
1
-
4
43
52
100
6
Currently there is already
Information about knowledge
and Disaster Risk training that
is easily accessible for
terminal users
16
15
14
37
18
100
7
Arjosari Terminal needs to
conduct regular Disaster Risk
Evaluation.
1
3
12
47
37
100
8
Currently, Arjosari Terminal
has provided a disaster
emergency response action
plan that is known to all
terminal users.
18
13
22
32
15
100
9
Terminal users already know
and understand the disaster
early warning system installed
at Arjosari Terminal
14
16
26
29
15
100
10
Currently, Disaster
Preparedness Procedures are
available at Arjosari Terminal
20
12
19
31
18
100
11
Arjosari Terminal officers
have conveyed to Terminal
users about the disaster
evacuation map
19
12
18
30
21
100
12
Arjosari Terminal needs to
provide a field as a gathering
point in the event of a disaster
1
4
19
36
40
100
13
Do you agree, if during a
disaster Arjosari Terminal
3
3
14
30
50
100
Vol 2, No 8 August 2023
Analysis Of The Needs Of Type A Terminal Infrastructure
Facilities In Arjosari, Malang Based On Disaster Mitigation
https://jetbis.al-makkipublisher.com/index.php/al/index
No
Question
Frekuensi
Sum
STS
TS
R
S
SS
becomes a Temporary
Evacuation Site?
Sum
167
135
217
462
319
1.300
Percentage (%)
12,85
%
10,38
%
16,69
%
35,54
%
24,54
%
100,0
%
Source: Researcher's processed data, 2023
Based on table 3 above, it can be seen that respondents' answers to questions on the capacity
variable were 35.54% of respondents' answers, namely agree, 24.54% strongly agree, 16.69%
undecided, 10.38% disagree and 12.85% strongly disagree. From each question it can be concluded
that education to terminal users is needed, besides that the terminal is expected to be a temporary
evacuation place in the event of a disaster.
Interview Analysis Results
This interview was conducted to parties related to this research, such as BNPB Malang City,
BPTD Region XI East Java Province and Head of Arjosari Terminal Service Unit, Malang.
Table 4
Summary of Interview Results with Respondents
Question
Explanation from Respondents
Potential disasters that may
occur at Arjosari Terminal
Extreme weather and strong winds, with a pattern of
strong wind movement from north to south, namely
from Bale Arjosari - Arjosari - Pandan Wangi.
The earthquake was only in the form of propagation
from an active fault in Malang Regency.
There is potential from volcanoes, but until now it has
never happened.
Flood
Damage and loss of life as a
result of the disaster
Terdapat kerusakan infrastuktur seperti atap bangunan.
Pohon tumbang
The strength of the Arjosari
Terminal building
Perlu dilakukan pengujian lebih lanjut.
Is a Disaster Mitigation-based
Terminal Needed?
Sangat diperlukan, apalagi Terminal merupakan fasilitas
umum, dimana banyak orang yang 578alua578 ke tempat
tersebut
What needs to be considered so
that the terminal building can
respond to disasters?
Struktur bangunan terminal sudah memperhitungkan
beban gempa
Struktur bangunan juga adaptif terhadap angin kencang.
Bangunan memiliki prinsip mengurangi resiko
bencana.
Memiliki drainase yang baik dan kantong-kantong air
hujan
Is it possible for the terminal
The terminal can be a temporary evacuation site.
Analysis Of The Needs Of Type A Terminal Infrastructure
Facilities In Arjosari, Malang Based On Disaster Mitigation
Vol 2, No 8 August 2023
https://jetbis.al-makkipublisher.com/index.php/al/index
579
Question
Explanation from Respondents
building to become a temporary
evacuation site?
Is there a need for socialization
to terminal users related to
disaster response?
A disaster-aware culture is PR for the government.
Source: Researcher's processed data, 2023
From the results of the interview, it is known that Arjosari Terminal still has potential disasters
that must be watched out for by all teminal users. The terminal building is expected to have been
adaptive to frequent disasters such as strong wind disasters (extreme weather). In addition, the
terminal building structure must take into account the earthquake load, although Malang City does
not have an active fault, but still often gets propagation from active faults in Malang Regency. To
reduce casualties, a terminal building that has disaster mitigation insights is needed.
Building Vulnerability Evaluation Results
Evaluation of the vulnerability of buildings to earthquakes is simply carried out using Rapid
Visual Screening (RVS). The input data needed to calculate the final value of the building
vulnerability level can be explained as follows:
1. Location Seismicity
The location of seismicity is the location of earthquake distribution, which in FEMA 154
(2015) is divided into five levels, namely low, medium, rather high, high and very high as shown
in table 5.
Table 5
Pembagian Lokasi Seismisitas
Location
Seismicity
Spectrum
Response
Acceleration/SS
(short period/0.2t)
Spectrum Response
Acceleration/S1
(long period/0.1t)
Rendah Low
S
S
< 0,25g
S
1
< 0,10g
Sedang Keep
0,25g S
S
< 0,50g
0,10g S
1
< 0,20g
A bit high
0,50g S
S
< 1,00g
0,20g S
1
< 0,40g
Tall
1,00g S
S
< 1,50g
0,40g S
1
< 0,60g
Very High
S
S
≥ 1,50g
S
1
≥ 0,60g
Source : FEMA 154, 2015
To determine the location of seismicity, an acceleration value is needed between the response
of the SS and S1 spectra at the location under review (Zulfiar, 2018). Spectral design data (SS and
S1) obtained coordinates of the location of the building under review, then inputted into the website
of the Center for Settlement Research and Development (https://rsa.ciptakarya.pu.go.id/2021/)
(Ministry of Public Works and Housing, 2011). The coordinates of the building with latitude -
7.933225 and longitude 112.658066, then from the coordinate input results obtained SS values of
0.8502 and S1 of 0.3995. Based on the acceleration of SS and S1 values, it shows the location of
seismicity in the category "Moderatly High".
1. Number of Floors
Vol 2, No 8 August 2023
Analysis Of The Needs Of Type A Terminal Infrastructure
Facilities In Arjosari, Malang Based On Disaster Mitigation
https://jetbis.al-makkipublisher.com/index.php/al/index
The number of floors is calculated from the lowest part of the building that touches the
ground to the roof (Zulfiar, 2018). Based on the results of surveys in the field, Arjosari Terminal
is as many as two floors with building height
1. Building identity
Arjosari Terminal was built in 1989, with a terminal area of ± 28,150 m2.
2. Residential type/class
Residential types/classes based on the RVS method are grouped into nine types, namely,
commercial buildings, public buildings, emergency service buildings, residential buildings,
industrial buildings, utility buildings, educational buildings and warehouse buildings (FEMA
154, 2015). The object of research of Arjosari Terminal can be categorized as a commercial
building.
3. Soil Type
Based on the Journal of Earthquake Prone Zoning in Malang City Based on Horizontal
Vertical to Spectral Ratio (HVSR) Analysis in 2016, the Arjosari area uses the zhao tread class
included in class II / Hard soil type (Research et al., n.d.) with shear wave speed (VS30) = 350
m/s < VS30 < 750 m/s or equal to 1148.29 ft/s < VS30 < 2460.63 ft/s (Edison, 2022). So for soil
types in FEMA 154 (2015) included in type C soils (Solid Soil, 1200 ft/s < VS30 < 2500 ft/s).
4. Building Type
According to FEMA 154 (2015), building types are classified into 17 building types. This
classification is based on the structural system used. Based on observations on the object of
study, it is included in the type of brick wall building with a moment-bearing concrete frame
structure with a brick wall without reinforcement (C3).
5. Vertical Irregularity
Vertical Irregularity is the appearance of irregular vertical buildings, such as:
a. Sloping Site, a building on a steep hill;
b. Soft story, a condition where a building floor has less power than the floor above or below it;
c. Out of plane seatback, a floor is not aligned vertically with the seismic force containment
system above or below it;
d. In plane seatback, the seismic force at the upper level is offset by elements of the seismic force
containment system at the lower level;
e. Short coloumn, when some columns are shorter than the usual columns;
f. Split levels, this condition occurs if the floors of the building are not aligned or if there is a
difference in roof height in one part of the building.
Based on observations on the object of research, for Vertical Irregularity, Arjosari
Terminal is included in the split levels.
6. Plan Irregularity
Plan Irregularity is the irregularity of the shape of the floor plan (not symmetrical).
Analysis Of The Needs Of Type A Terminal Infrastructure
Facilities In Arjosari, Malang Based On Disaster Mitigation
Vol 2, No 8 August 2023
https://jetbis.al-makkipublisher.com/index.php/al/index
581
Figure 8
Plan Irregularity Reference Guide
Source: FEMA 154, 2015
Based on observations on the object of research, for Plan Irregularity, Arjosari Terminal is
included in the reentrant corner.
1. Rules used at the time of building (Code)
Code can be known by looking at when the building was erected. For codes applicable in
Indonesia, they are as follows:
Pre-code: if built before 1971 (PBI 1971).
Post-Benchmark: if built after 1992 (SNI 1992).
2. Falling hazard
Arjosari Terminal has a falling hazard exterior in the form of a building roof frame in the
form of a porous wooden frame.
3. Final Score
The final score (S) of a building can be obtained by summing each number from the criteria
mentioned earlier on the RVS form provided. If the value of S 2, then the evaluated building
has a high risk due to earthquakes so that a more detailed evaluation is needed (FEMA 154, 2015).
Based on these criteria, the final score can be calculated, namely by summing all the values
that have been determined on the RVS FEMA P-154 form, namely 1.4 + (-0.5) + (-0.6) + 0.3 =
0.6. So a final value of 0.6 is obtained where the value is greater than the minimum value of 0.3.
Because the final value (S) ≤ 2, the evaluated building has a high risk due to earthquakes so a
more detailed evaluation is needed.
Vol 2, No 8 August 2023
Analysis Of The Needs Of Type A Terminal Infrastructure
Facilities In Arjosari, Malang Based On Disaster Mitigation
https://jetbis.al-makkipublisher.com/index.php/al/index
Figure 9
Filling Arjosari Terminal RVS formular
Source: Researcher's processed data, 2023
After calculating the final value, the next step is to calculate the potential vulnerability of
the Arjosari Terminal building as the following table:
Table 6
Results of Analysis of Potential Vulnerability of Arjosari Terminal Building
Building Name
Terminal Arjosari
Building Category
C3
Final Grade (Score)
0,6
10S
3,981072
1/10
S
0,2511
Building Vulnerability Potential
(%)
25,12%
Source : Data processed by researchers, 2023
Analysis Of The Needs Of Type A Terminal Infrastructure
Facilities In Arjosari, Malang Based On Disaster Mitigation
Vol 2, No 8 August 2023
https://jetbis.al-makkipublisher.com/index.php/al/index
583
From the table, it can be seen that the Arjosari Terminal building has an S value of 0.6. The
potential vulnerability of the Arjosari Terminal building to earthquakes has a percentage of 25.12%,
which informs that the percentage of vulnerability of this building is quite large, so the building
requires maintenance to increase the strength of the building.
Results of Analysis of the existing condition of terminal infrastructure facilities
Facilities and infrastructure in Arjosari Terminal require evaluation of the 2006 Earthquake
Resistant Building Technical Guidelines issued by the Department of Public Works. The evaluation
results can be seen as the following table:
Table 6
Existing Conditions of Terminal Facilities and Infrastructure
No
Item
Data Lapangan
Rekomendasi
1.
Building layout
Buildings are built on plain land that
has a rigid soil type.
Sudah baik.
2.
Building height
The Main Building has 2 levels with
a total height of 7 m, while other
buildings have 1 level with a height
of 3.5 m. The height of the building
does not exceed four times the width
of the building.
It's been good.
3.
Building plan
Simple but not symmetrical building
plan
There needs to be
improvement.
4.
The presence of
structural
elements
Columns, beams and slof are
reinforced concrete.
Walls with red masonry
It's been good.
5.
Building weight
For roof construction using wood
materials, so it has a heavy load and
burdens on the structure below. But
because the Arjosari area has the
potential for extreme weather with a
high angle, the use of wood
construction has advantages
compared to material from mild
steel. But at some point it has already
experienced damage.
There is a need for repair of
the roof frame and
replacement of roof covering
material with metal.
6.
Terminal room layout
The arrangement of waiting room
seats in the passenger waiting area
is good, can provide balanced
access, so as to facilitate evacuation
during a disaster.
It's been good.
7.
Door openings
For terminal users: the building has
open space that makes it easy for
passenger mobilization, but there is
a sterilization fence along the
passenger departure lounge.
It is necessary to improve the
direction of door openings in
the terminal management
building and openings at
several points on the
sterilization fence.
Vol 2, No 8 August 2023
Analysis Of The Needs Of Type A Terminal Infrastructure
Facilities In Arjosari, Malang Based On Disaster Mitigation
https://jetbis.al-makkipublisher.com/index.php/al/index
No
Item
Data Lapangan
Rekomendasi
As for terminal officers who work
on the 2nd floor of the main
building, there are 9 rooms with all
doors having inward openings.
8.
Outbound access
Access to the exit door is wide open,
but is blocked by a sterilization fence
along the passenger lounge.
There needs to be an opening
in the sterilization fence that
can be opened easily during
emergency conditions.
9.
Supporting
facilities for
disaster risk
reduction
The terminal building is surrounded
by roads making it easy for
mobilization.
D2apat is used in emergency
conditions for
rehabilitation/reconstruction.
10.
Evacuation
routes and
gathering points
Already exists
There is a need to increase
the number of signs and
improve the road area
heading to the gathering
point, so as not to cause
casualties when running
towards the location.
11.
Disaster posters
Nothing yet
Need to be made.
Source : Researcher's Processed Data, 2023
Based on table 6, the existing condition of existing infrastructure facilities at Arjosari Terminal
requires maintenance so that each facility can function optimally, repair efforts at Arjosari Terminal
should be carried out as soon as possible considering the large number of terminal users every day.
Results of Analysis of the needs of disaster mitigation-based infrastructure facilities.
Potential danger is something that has the potential for incidents to occur that result in losses.
Based on a disaster risk assessment conducted by BPBD Malang City in 2021, the potential disasters
that occur in the Arjosari Village area are extreme weather, floods, and earthquakes. In times of
extreme weather there are often strong winds.
To deal with disasters that may occur, one of the mitigations carried out is structural
mitigation. Structural mitigation is an effort to reduce disaster risk carried out through the
construction of various physical infrastructure. Structural mitigations to be implemented at Arjosari
Terminal are as follows:
Table 7
Structural Mitigation Plan at Arjosari Terminal
No
Structural Mitigation
Plan
Information
1
Repair of the roof of the
terminal building
1) Many parts of the roof of the terminal building
have been damaged, porous and perforated, so
repairs are needed.
Analysis Of The Needs Of Type A Terminal Infrastructure
Facilities In Arjosari, Malang Based On Disaster Mitigation
Vol 2, No 8 August 2023
https://jetbis.al-makkipublisher.com/index.php/al/index
585
No
Structural Mitigation
Plan
Information
2) Because of the potential for strong winds, the roof
of the terminal building must be adaptive to
strong winds.
a. The roof structure uses a
gable roof.
This shield roof is suitable for areas with heavy rain,
but it is also more resistant to wind.
b. The roof truss structure
uses wood material.
The wooden roof frame has a strong texture and is
also durable.
c. The roof covering
material uses metal tiles.
Metal tile has the following advantages:
3) More durable and durable.
4) Maintenance is easy.
5) Provide coolness into the building.
6) Muffle noise from the sound of rain and lightning.
7) Resistant to fire.
8) It has a sturdy nature so that when there are strong
winds, storms and heavy rain have strong
endurance.
d. It is necessary to install
ceilings in terminal office
buildings and also other
rooms.
Protect the inside of the building in case of heavy
rain due to extreme weather, falling part of the roof
of the building.
2
Pavement repairs in the
departure shelter and arrival
shelter areas.
The purpose of carrying out this activity is to
maintain road conditions to continue to function
optimally. In addition, it can provide security,
comfort and safety for terminal users who cross it in
the event of a disaster. Damaged roads can hinder
mobilization and result in casualties.
3
Door and window repair
Based on the Regulation of the Minister of Public
Works Number 29 of 2006, the direction of door and
window openings must be outward.
Source : Data processed by researchers, 2023
Based on the table above, the next step is to compile a cost estimate in the maintenance of
terminal infrastructure based on disaster mitigation.
Vol 2, No 8 August 2023
Analysis Of The Needs Of Type A Terminal Infrastructure
Facilities In Arjosari, Malang Based On Disaster Mitigation
https://jetbis.al-makkipublisher.com/index.php/al/index
Pos Pantau
Figure 4
Floor Plan of Arjosari Terminal Malang
Source: Researcher's processed data, 2023
Based on the floor plan drawing, it can be calculated the maintenance needs of the Arjosari
terminal based on disaster mitigation.
1. Pavement repair
The extent of the pavement to be repaired is as follows:
Area = Length x width
= 110 m x 90.3 m
= 9,936.20 m2
2. Repair of the roof of the main building and monitoring post
Repairs are needed on the roof of the main building and monitoring post with detailed calculation
of area area as follows:
a. Main Building
The calculation of the area of the roof area to be repaired in the main building is as follows:
Area of main building = Length x width
= 25 m x 21 m
= 525 m
2
b. Watchpost
The calculation of the roof area to be repaired at the monitoring post is as follows:
Watchpost area = Length x width
= 2 m x 3 m
= 6 m
2
Bangunan Utama
Area perkerasan shelter yang
akan diperbaiki
Analysis Of The Needs Of Type A Terminal Infrastructure
Facilities In Arjosari, Malang Based On Disaster Mitigation
Vol 2, No 8 August 2023
https://jetbis.al-makkipublisher.com/index.php/al/index
587
Table 8
rencana anggaran biaya
No
Work
Theft
Unit
Unit
Price
Total
Kingdom
1
Roof
Demolition
531
m2
157.206
83.476.386
2
Ceiling
Demolition
531
m2
39.644
21.050.964
3
Pavement
demolition
9.936,20
m2
583.107
5.793.866.024
4
Roof Work
-
5
Installation of
ceramic tile
roof frame,
Class II wood
531
m2
566.474
300.797.694
6
Roof
covering:
Metal Roof
Tile Size 80 x
100 Gable
Roof
531
m2
162.611
86.346.441
7
Coating :
Allumunium
foil
531
m2
84.507
44.873.217
8
Asbestos
ceiling
installation
(1.00 x 1.00)
m x 3.5 mm +
camphor
wood frame
531
m2
291.653
154.867.743
9
Cement
Concrete
Pavement
Repair
9.936,20
m2
1.460.933
14.516.118.092
10
Procurement
and
installation of
Evacuation
Signs
3,00
Unit
795.804
2.387.412
Sum
21.003.783.973
PPN 11%
2.310.416.237
Total
Amount
23.314.200.210
Based on table 4 above, the estimated cost required for Arjosari Terminal maintenance to be
adaptive to disasters is Rp. 23,314,209,210,-. With the largest number of repairs located on the
pavement section in the terminal shelter area.
Vol 2, No 8 August 2023
Analysis Of The Needs Of Type A Terminal Infrastructure
Facilities In Arjosari, Malang Based On Disaster Mitigation
https://jetbis.al-makkipublisher.com/index.php/al/index
CONCLUSION
From the research, it can be concluded that the potential vulnerability of terminal buildings to
earthquakes is quite high and there is damage to several terminal infrastructure. Based on this, it is
necessary to repair / rehabilitate the terminal building or revitalization can also be done to improve
the quality of the Arjosari Terminal building. In this study, researchers suggested that a more detailed
evaluation of the condition of the terminal building against earthquakes should be carried out.
Evaluation can be done using FEMA 310, FEMA 356, ATC 40, Tier 1 (static linear analysis), Tier
2 (dynamic linear analysis) and Tier 3 (non linear analysis). In addition, for non-structural
mitigation, periodic evaluation of building reliability in accordance with Government Regulation
Number 16 of 2021 concerning Implementing Regulations of Law Number 28 of 2002 concerning
Building to maintain building conditions, especially public facility buildings, remain in optimal
condition during a disaster. and also coordinate with relevant agencies to conduct socialization and
simulations related to disasters at Arjosari Terminal.
DAFTAR PUSTAKA
Agustin, S., Djauhari, Z., & Suryanita, R. (2020). Aplikasi Metode Rapid Visual Screening (RVS)
Dalam Monitoring Kerentanan Bangunan Pemerintahan di Indragiri Hulu. Jurnal Rekayasa
Sipil, 16(1), 3848. Google Scholar
Agustin, S., Suryanita, R., & Djauhari, Z. (2019). Monitoring Kerentanan Bangunan Gedung
Dengan Metode Rapid Visual Screening. Sainstek (e-Journal), 7(1), 1531. Google Scholar
Amir, F. (2012). Evaluasi Kerentanan Bangunan Gedung Terhadap Gempa Bumi Dengan Rapid
Visual Screening (RVS) Berdasarkan FEMA 154. Journal Teknik Sipil Dan Infrastruktur,
2(1). Google Scholar
Bakornas, P. B. (2007). Pengenalan karakteristik bencana dan upaya mitigasinya di Indonesia.
Jakarta: Badan Nasional Penanggulangan Bencana. Google Scholar
Bencana, B. N. P. (2020). Rencana Nasional Penanggulangan Bencana 2020-2024. BNPB, Jakarta,
1, 115. Google Scholar
Birawaputra, I., & Tethool, Y. C. V. (2019). Penggunaan Metode Rapid Visual Screening Dalam
Menentukan Kerentanan Bangunan Akibat Gempa Bumi. INTAN Jurnal Penelitian Tambang,
2(2), 97105. Google Scholar
Edison, R., Prakoso, W. A., & Rohadi, S. (2022). Pemetaan Vs30 Dengan Menggunakan Korelasi
Zhao Di Pesisir Cilacap. Jurnal Geosaintek, 8(1), 181190. Google Scholar
Hakim, A. Y. Al, & Sulistijo, B. (2013). Integrated Exploration Method to Determine Cu Prospect
in Seweden District, Blitar, East Java. Procedia Earth and Planetary Science, 6, 6469.
https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.proeps.2013.01.009. Google Scholar
Negara, L. (2007). Undang-undang republik indonesia nomor 24 tahun 2007 tentang
penanggulangan bencana. Jakarta. Google Scholar
Putra, M. A., & Ismail, T. (2022). Coastal Area Development Through Mangrove Planting and Tree
Foster Parents (OTAP) as Climate Change Restoration and Mitigation Efforts Sedari Village,
Cibuaya District, Karawang Regency. Journal of World Science, 1(10), 856863. Google
Scholar
Suharwoto, G., Nurwin, N., & TD, N. (2015). Modul 1, Pilar 1, fasilitas sekolah aman. Google
Scholar
Analysis Of The Needs Of Type A Terminal Infrastructure
Facilities In Arjosari, Malang Based On Disaster Mitigation
Vol 2, No 8 August 2023
https://jetbis.al-makkipublisher.com/index.php/al/index
589
Utami, S. N. (2022). Apa yang Menyebabkan Indonesia Rawan terhadap Bencana Alam. Google
Scholar
Wahyuni, L. (2018). MODEL KAMPUS BERWAWASAN MITIGASI BENCANA GEMPA BUMI:
Studi Kasus: Kampus UPI Bumi Siliwangi. Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia. Google Scholar
licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License